Both are highly rated, both have short waiting periods — but they differ significantly on age restrictions, annual limits, and what happens when your pet gets older.
Healthy Paws reduces coverage options for pets enrolled at age 5 or older. At age 6 and above, they permanently exclude hip dysplasia — one of the most expensive orthopedic conditions in dogs. For a Golden Retriever, German Shepherd, or Labrador owner, this is significant.
Pumpkin has no age-based coverage restrictions. A 7-year-old dog enrolling with Pumpkin gets the same coverage options as a puppy.
If your dog is 4 years old and healthy: Enroll with Healthy Paws now, before the age-5 and age-6 thresholds hit. You lock in full coverage at better terms. Waiting even one year can mean permanently losing hip dysplasia coverage.
Healthy Paws has no annual payout limit — a significant advantage for serious conditions. Cancer treatment can run $10,000-25,000. A dog with both a CCL surgery and a cancer diagnosis in the same year could easily exceed $20,000 in covered expenses.
Pumpkin caps annual payouts at $20,000, which covers most situations but not the worst-case scenarios for large breeds with multiple issues.
Pumpkin covers exam fees, Healthy Paws does not. For a pet with frequent vet visits — chronic skin issues, recurring infections, senior wellness — exam fees at $50-100 each add up meaningfully over a year.
Best choice for most young dogs: Healthy Paws, if enrolled before age 5. The unlimited annual payout and 15-day orthopedic wait are hard to beat. Enroll early and lock in full terms before the age restrictions apply.
Your pet is under 5 years old, healthy, and a breed prone to expensive orthopedic or cancer conditions. The unlimited payout and short orthopedic wait make Healthy Paws the strongest coverage for worst-case scenarios — if you enroll early.
Your pet is 5 or older, you want exam fees covered, or you need a consistent 90% reimbursement rate with no age-based restrictions. Pumpkin is also the better choice for cats where HCM cardiac issues are a concern and age restrictions would be limiting.
Upload your pet's vet records and PawClaim shows what Healthy Paws and Pumpkin would each exclude, which age restrictions apply, and which saves you more money.
Scan my vet records free