Spot and Pumpkin share the same underwriter and have nearly identical prices — but differ on plan flexibility, reimbursement options, and what is included in the base policy.
Important: Spot and Pumpkin are both underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company. Their core coverage terms are very similar. The differences are mostly in plan structure, not in what gets covered or excluded at the claims level.
Reimbursement rate: Pumpkin fixes reimbursement at 90%. Spot offers 70%, 80%, or 90% — giving budget-conscious owners the option to lower premiums by accepting a lower reimbursement rate.
Exam fees: Pumpkin includes exam fees in the base policy. Spot requires an add-on. For a pet with frequent vet visits, this matters — exam fees at $50-100 each add up through the year.
Annual limit: Spot offers plans starting at $2,500 (useful for very budget-conscious owners) up to unlimited. Pumpkin caps at $20,000. If your pet is a cancer-prone breed, Spot's unlimited option is a meaningful advantage.
Curable pre-existing conditions: Spot will reconsider excluded conditions after 12 symptom-free months. Pumpkin does not — once excluded, always excluded.
Both have 14-day orthopedic waits — one of the shortest in the industry. For large breed dogs this is a meaningful advantage over insurers with 6-month orthopedic waits. Neither insurer disadvantages you on orthopedic coverage timing.
Spot and Pumpkin prices are nearly identical — typically within $1-2 per month for comparable coverage. Pumpkin is cheaper for senior pets; Spot is cheaper for kittens and young cats. For most pet owners, price will not be the deciding factor between these two.
You want more plan flexibility, an unlimited annual payout option, curable pre-existing condition reconsideration, or a lower-reimbursement plan to reduce monthly premiums. Spot is also better for pets with minor past conditions you want to recover after 12 months.
You want exam fees included without an add-on, a fixed 90% reimbursement with no decisions to make, and a simpler policy structure. Pumpkin is also rated higher for customer satisfaction and claims experience in most independent studies.
Paste your pet's vet records and PawClaim shows what Spot and Pumpkin would each exclude for your specific pet.
Scan my vet records free