Your renewal notice arrives and the premium jumped 40%. A competitor is advertising the same coverage for half the price. Switching seems obvious.
For a young pet with clean records, it often is. For everyone else, switching pet insurance is one of the most expensive mistakes a pet owner can make - and the cost is invisible until the first denied claim.
When you enroll with a new insurer, they review your pet's complete veterinary history. Everything in those records - diagnoses, symptoms, medications, even suspicions that were never confirmed - becomes a pre-existing condition at the new company.
The conditions your current insurer covers today, because they developed after you enrolled, would never be covered again.
A real example: A 9-year-old Lab with managed elbow dysplasia and early kidney values on watch. Current insurer covers both (they developed post-enrollment). Premium went from $87 to $134/month. Switching would save perhaps $50/month - but kidney disease management alone costs $200-500/month, and every dollar of it would come out of pocket at the new insurer. The "expensive" renewal is the better deal by thousands per year.
This is the big one. Chronic conditions - allergies, joint disease, kidney values, heart murmurs, thyroid issues - follow your pet in their records. The new insurer excludes them all, permanently in most cases.
New policy means new waiting periods: up to 30 days for illness, up to 6 months for orthopedic conditions. Anything that happens during those windows is denied and potentially excluded forever.
If your vet ever wrote "rule out diabetes" or "suspected Cushing's" - even if the follow-up test was clean or never done - the new insurer can treat that condition as pre-existing. Unconfirmed suspicions in the records are enough.
If your dog had a problem in one knee, one ear, or one eye, most insurers exclude the other side too. A left CCL tear before switching means neither knee is covered at the new company - and CCL surgery runs $3,500-6,000 per knee.
Some insurers reduce reimbursement options at age 5, exclude hip dysplasia at 6, or only offer accident-only plans at 9+. Your current policy grandfathered you in; a new one applies today's age rules.
Before you switch, always: (1) request your pet's full vet records, (2) ask the NEW insurer for a written pre-existing condition review before you cancel anything, (3) keep the old policy active until the new one's waiting periods have fully passed.
Renewal increases feel unfair, but run the numbers before reacting:
If your pet has even one covered chronic condition, the renewal increase is almost always the cheaper path.
Upload your pet's vet records and PawClaim shows exactly which conditions each insurer would exclude, which waiting periods would apply, and whether switching actually saves you money.
Scan my vet records free →