Every week you wait to enroll your pet in insurance is a week during which a new condition can develop and become permanently excluded. Pet insurance works on a simple principle: it only covers conditions that develop after your policy starts. The earlier you enroll, the more conditions your policy can cover.
The best time to get pet insurance is when your pet is 8-16 weeks old. At this age: there are no pre-existing conditions to exclude, premiums are at their lowest, you get full coverage for hereditary conditions that may appear later, and orthopedic waiting periods will expire before your pet reaches the age when joint issues typically develop (usually 1-3 years for large breeds). Most insurers accept puppies and kittens as young as 8 weeks old.
Enrolling a healthy 1-3 year old dog or cat is still an excellent time. Most serious hereditary conditions have not yet manifested, premiums are still relatively low, and you have years of comprehensive coverage ahead. The key is "healthy", if any conditions have already been noted in vet records, those will be excluded from day one.
This is one of the most time-sensitive windows: if your pet has been acting differently or you have noticed something concerning, enroll before taking them to the vet if at all possible. Once a vet notes a symptom or concern in their records, that condition can be classified as pre-existing. This does not mean hiding health issues, it means not delaying enrollment unnecessarily.
Large breed dogs have elevated orthopedic risk between ages 1-4. Golden Retrievers and Rottweilers have elevated cancer risk from middle age onward. If you have a high-risk breed and have not yet enrolled, do so before these windows open. Waiting until the risk materializes means the coverage will not apply.
If your pet already has documented health conditions, insurance can still provide value for new conditions that develop in the future. The existing conditions will be excluded, but a new injury or illness after enrollment will be covered. For pets with multiple existing conditions, the calculus becomes harder and depends on how many conditions are excluded vs how much coverage remains meaningful.
Key takeaways
PawScore analyzes your pet's age, breed, and health history to tell you whether your current coverage makes sense.
Check My PawScore Free →Ask a question →