Cat insurance costs an average of $32/month (NAPHIA 2025), making it one of the more affordable insurance decisions a pet owner can make. Indoor cats live longer (often 15-20 years) and have lower accident risk than outdoor cats or dogs, but they are not immune to expensive illnesses, urinary blockages, diabetes, cancer, and hyperthyroidism are all common and costly.
The most common expensive conditions in indoor cats include: urinary blockages ($1,500-$3,000 and life-threatening if untreated), diabetes ($800-$2,000/year in ongoing insulin and monitoring), hyperthyroidism ($300-$3,000 depending on treatment method including radioactive iodine therapy), cancer (lymphoma is common in cats, $3,000-$8,000), and dental disease ($500-$2,000 for extractions). None of these are outdoor-cat-specific.
Indoor cats routinely live 15-20 years. At $32/month, you pay about $384/year in premiums. Over 15 years, that is roughly $5,760 in premiums. A single urinary blockage, cancer diagnosis, or dental surgery can cost $1,500-$8,000. Most cat owners encounter at least one of these over a 15-year lifespan.
Purebred cats have meaningfully elevated health risks. Maine Coons and Ragdolls carry HCM (heart disease) risk. Persians are prone to kidney disease. Siamese have elevated cancer and dental disease rates. Bengals are prone to progressive retinal atrophy. For purebred cats, insurance is a clearer decision than for mixed-breed domestic shorthairs.
Accident-only plans are much cheaper ($9/month average) but miss most of what actually happens to indoor cats. Illnesses, not accidents, are the primary risk for indoor cats. An accident-only plan for an indoor cat is likely not worth the premium. Accident and illness plans at $32/month provide meaningful protection.
Pet insurance is worth it for most indoor cats, particularly purebred cats and cats whose owners would pursue full treatment for serious illness. The low monthly cost ($32/month average) makes the break-even math favorable.
PawScore analyzes your specific policy, breed, and age to tell you whether you are getting value, and what to change if not.
Check My PawScore Free →Cost Calculator →