Why Odie denies claims for this reason
▸One knee, hip, or ear had a prior condition and the insurer is now excluding the other side
▸The policy bilateral exclusion language is broad and the insurer is applying it aggressively
▸A traumatic injury on one side is being linked to a hereditary condition on the other
Your strongest appeal arguments
✓Argue the current injury is a new, independent traumatic event with a different cause than the prior one.
✓Ask your vet to put in writing that the two conditions are clinically unrelated.
✓Ask the insurer to cite the exact policy clause that triggers the bilateral exclusion. Many require the conditions to be related, which may not apply here.
✓If the first condition was hereditary and the second was traumatic, the etiology is different. Make this argument explicitly.
Documents to gather before you appeal
✓Full vet records for both the prior and current condition
✓A vet statement confirming the two conditions are clinically independent with different causes
✓Your policy's exact bilateral exclusion definition
✓The denial letter citing the specific exclusion clause
Timeline
Appeal within 30 days of the denial. Bilateral exclusion appeals with strong vet documentation have a reasonable track record.
If your appeal is denied again
Not sure where to start?
Upload your denial letter and get a free breakdown of your case before you write anything.
1
Free: Upload your letter. We tell you exactly why it was denied and whether your case is worth appealing.
2
Free: Get the arguments and document checklist specific to your insurer and denial type.
3
Pro ($8/mo): We write the full appeal letter citing your insurer's own policy language, and pre-fill your state DOI complaint if needed.
No account needed to start. Takes about 60 seconds.
Need the appeal letter written for you?
Pro members get a complete appeal letter citing Odie's policy language, a pre-filled DOI complaint, and unlimited follow-up questions.
Get Pro, $8/mo ›Cancel anytime. No contracts.
Bilateral Exclusion at other insurers